4.4 Self-Test A on Argumentation

I. Can you recognize parts of an introduction? Read the introduction below and then answer the following True/False questions.

Introduction

(1) Coping with life has always had a dangerous element because of the human potential for manipulation and acquisitiveness which challenge people's safety and well-being. (2) In this context "manipulation" means "humans' ability to control and exploit" at their will, while the term "acquisitiveness" refers to "their greed and selfishness". (3) The writer will examine the quality of life in the second half of the twentieth century to see what factors contribute to or detract from the measure of safety and welfare people enjoy. (4) In doing so, the writer will emphasise technological advances and personal freedom. (5) Living in the second half of the twentieth century has greater hazards because people have more scope for manipulation and acquisitiveness through knowledge explosion and a heightened sense of self-preoccupation.

1. Sentence 4 expresses the purpose of the essay. True False

2. Sentence 2 orientates to the topic. True False

3. Sentence 5 is the thesis statement.True False

II. Examine the following jumbled introduction and select the appropriate answer.

Jumbled introduction

(1) This essay will review the history of the science of earthquake prediction to establish the success-failure rate of each method. (2) Earthquakes are the most destructive natural disasters known to humans in terms of the millions of deaths and billions of dollars in property loss they cause. (3) Different methods of prediction, such as animal behaviour and the measuring of radio signals from qasars will be examined. (4) Despite the use of advanced scientific and technological methods, scientists are still unable to predict earthquakes.

4. Sentence one (1) is
Thesis statement Scope/limit Purpose of essay

5. Sentence two (2) is
Purpose of essay Orientation Thesis statement

6. Sentence two (3) is
Scope/limit Purpose of essay Thesis statement

7. Sentence two (2) is
Orientation Purpose of essay Thesis statement

8. Paragraphs must contain topic sentences. True False

9. The writer does not have to make a link between paragraphs when a new topic is introduced. True False

10. The writer produces evidence in the paragraph and that is all that is needed, apart from the topic sentence. True False

11. The conclusion of the essay is the only place a summary sentence is used. True False

12. The writer's voice is never heard in the essay. True False

13. The opening line of the conclusion of an essay should contain the re-worded thesis statement. True False

14. The conclusion should sum up the argumentation from each section of the essay. True False

15. The argumentation in each section of the essay does not have to be linked to the thesis statement. True False

16. A writer should be aware of the underlying assumptions in the set essay question. True False

17. Identification of the assumptions in the set essay question assists the writer to unravel the areas for argumentation. True False

18. In order to argue satisfactorily the question posed, the writer must ensure that he/she fulfils all the requirements set out in the assignment question. True False